By emptying death row, Newsom broke a promise and disregarded the will of voters

0
1

By Dan Walters
SPECIAL FOR CALMATTERS
This commentary was originally published by CalMatters.

Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute the death sentences of 548 inmates just weeks before he leaves office is the latest epi­sode in California’s 70-year-long political, legal and philosophical debate over capital punishment.

It also adds complexity, be­cause Newsom’s unilateral ef­forts to stop executions violate promises he made while run­ning for governor to honor vot­ers’ support of the death pen­alty.

While Newsom’s actions might bolster his standing among center-left Democratic voters in a potential presiden­tial campaign, a Pew Research Center poll in August found 68% of Americans see the death penalty as justified for those who commit murder. That’s 6 percentage points higher than the support in a 2021 poll.

A little history: California ad­opted capital punishment about when it became a state in 1850, but initially executions were do­ne by counties. The state took over in 1893, and since then 514 people have been put to death, according to state records.

Serious efforts to abolish Cali­fornia’s death penalty date from the 1950s, when Caryl Chess­man, dubbed the “Red Light Bandit,” faced execution for a series of robberies and sexual assaults — but no murders — in the 1940s and became a symbol for death penalty opponents.

Chessman’s fate finally land­ed with Democratic Gov. Pat Brown, who personally opposed capital punishment. In 1960, on the eve of Chessman’s execu­tion, Brown’s 21-year-old son, Jerry, pleaded for a reprieve and urged him to seek legislative re­peal. The elder Brown agreed but the Legislature balked, and Chessman was executed on May 2, 1960.

During the 1970s, California’s death penalty underwent a diz­zying series of legal and politi­cal moves — sometimes in ef­fect, sometimes not, depending on the latest decree from the state Supreme Court, action by the Legislature or ballot mea­sure.

Voters had the last word in a 1978 pro-death-penalty bal­lot measure. However, Jerry Brown, who had become gov­ernor, appointed several mem­bers of the Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice Rose Bird, who consistently rejected death sen­tences. Voters ousted Bird and two other justices in 1986

Executions resumed in the 1990s, and there have been 13 since. The last was triple mur­derer Clarence Ray Allen in 2006.

In 2012 and again in 2016, voters rejected ballot measures to repeal the death penalty while passing a 2016 measure aimed at speeding up capital punishment appeals.

Enter Newsom, who was elected lieutenant governor in 2010 and obviously wanted to become governor. In 2016, when asked about the death penalty by the Modesto Bee, Newsom said he would “be accountable to the will of the voters” if elect­ed governor.

“I would not get my personal opinions in the way of the pub­lic’s right to make a determina­tion of where they want to take us,” he said.

While campaigning in 2018, Newsom said he didn’t “want to get ahead of the will of the voters” and wanted to “give the voters a chance to reconsider.”

However, shortly after inaugu­ration in 2019, Newsom issued a moratorium on executions but ducked questions about asking voters to repeal capital punish­ment, which would have been the honorable way to proceed. Instead he waited until the fi­nal weeks of his governorship to commute death sentences, subject to state Supreme Court ratification of some cases.

“I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanc­tioned killing is incompatible with California’s values, un­dermines the foundation of our legal system, and diminishes each of us,” Newsom said in an open letter. “I know we cannot execute people in our imperfect legal system and remain true to our core values, first among them justice and human de­cency.”

Newsom insists he respects voters, “but the constitution also gave every governor clem­ency authority, and that power exists for moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice. For me, this is that moment.”

The authority he cites was aimed at righting perceived in­justices on a case-by-case basis.

Newsom’s blanket clemency distorts that process, thumbs his nose at California voters and dishonors victims of hor­rendous crimes and their griev­ing families.

We’ll learn whether it also im­pacts his presumed presidential ambitions.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here