Deportations would be costly to Americans

By Alliyah Lusuegro

President Trump has made it clear that he’s dead set on at­tacking our immigrant friends, families, and neighbors — and that the only people he’ll pro­tect are his loyalists and billion­aires.

Since day one, Trump has launched a blatantly hateful agenda against immigrants. He’s issued executive orders that would unlawfully shut down asylum at the U.S. south­ern border, use the military to separate families, and make it easier to detain and deport mi­grants — including detaining them at the notorious Guanta­namo Bay prison.

Meanwhile, anti-immigrant lawmakers in Congress gave Trump a helping hand by pass­ing a law punishing undocu­mented people, including mi­nors, with deportation for minor offenses — even if they’re not convicted.

These attacks come at an enormous cost to the entire country. The American Immi­gration Council estimates that mass deportations will cost $88 billion per year over the course of a decade.

My colleagues and I calcu­lated that this $88 billion could instead erase medical debt for 40 million Americans. Even just a fraction of it — $11 billion — could provide free lunch to all school children in the United States.

There are already 40,000 people locked up in detention centers — and Trump’s deten­tion expansion plan would tri­ple that capacity. Republicans in the House and Senate are proposing plans of an eye-pop­ping $175 billion or more to de­tain and deport undocumented people.

That’s enough to fund af­fordable housing for every un­housed person and household facing eviction in this country for several years — with about enough left over to make sure uninsured people with opioid use disorder can get treatment.

Nor are these the only costs. Undocumented people contrib­uted $96.7 billion in federal, state, and local taxes in 2022 — just one tax year, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy. That’s nearly $100 billion in lost revenue a year that everyone else would end up having to cover.

But these attacks aren’t going unopposed. People are showing up for their immigrant neigh­bors and loved ones, making clear they simply won’t accept the nightmare of mass deporta­tions and detentions.

The groups United We Dream, CASA, Make the Road States, and Action Lab recent­ly pledged to build “a strong and sustainable movement to defend ourselves and our neigh­bors.” With their #Communi­tiesNotCages campaign, Deten­tion Watch Network is working with local communities to pro­test ICE actions and shut down detention centers.

And the list goes on.

On February 1, thousands of people blocked a highway in Los Angeles to protest against ICE raids. Just two days later, many gathered in solidarity for a Day Without Immigrants. On this day, students stayed home from school, employees didn’t show up to work, and over 250 businesses closed nationwide to show how important immi­grants are to everyone’s day-to-day lives.

Others are using lawsuits to fight back. Five pregnant wom­en, with the help of immigrant rights groups, sued the Trump administration’s attempt to end birthright citizenship. Agreeing with the mothers, three federal judges just blocked this uncon­stitutional order.

Meanwhile, the American Civil Liberties Union and other major legal organizations sued the administration for seeking to shut down asylum at the bor­der — on the grounds that it’s a violation of long-time interna­tional and domestic law.

Finally, my fellow immi­grants and I are also standing our ground. We’re stating the facts: Immigration is good for our country, our economy, and our culture — something 68 percent of Americans agree with. And we’re here to stay.

Immigrants are essential to this country. We bring oppor­tunity and possibility to the United States. And not only do we contribute as students and professionals, business owners, and essential workers — we’re also human beings trying to live good and successful lives like anyone else. We’re a part of the American story.

Now and more than ever, we’ll continue to show up for each other — and we hope you will, too. Our lives and families de­pend on it.

Alliyah Lusuegro is the Outreach Coordinator for the National Pri­orities Project at the Institute for Policy Studies. This op-ed was distributed by OtherWords.org.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here